|
|
|
ESL /EFL Each year, thousands of people travel to a foreign country on their way to positions teaching English to the people of their host country. Often these teachers wonder how to serve the needs of the students in their classes, how to apply the ESL methods they have learned to the ESL/EFL environment they find, and how to earn the respect and thanks of the people they will teach.
This article is the result of two
surveys conducted in Hungary and China. Both surveys asked
teachers and students who have worked with American or other
native-speaking English teachers to express a
consumer's view of what works and what doesn't when a person is a
visiting teacher of their native language in another country.
|
||
|
|
|
You will probably teach some classes you didn't anticipate |
|
Learn non-American varieties of English, especially British. Students in other countries are confronted with many forms of English. Historically, British English has usually been preferred. While this situation is certainly no longer so clear, students now are exposed to teachers and materials from at least North America, Britain, Hong Kong, Australia, and New Zealand, and they are frustrated by instructors who correct what they learned from another native speaker. As a minimum, instructors teaching overseas need to be able to recognize the variant vocabulary, pronunciation, and syntactic forms of British and American English. Ideally, they should be able to help students master the written forms of either major variety and should be familiar with the forms found in other countries, as well. Learn about your students' language and about common error patterns. The biggest advantage of the L1-speaking teacher over the native-speaking teacher is that the L1-speaking teacher can quickly make a complex grammatical point by a comparison to an L1 structure or by using L1 terms. The more you can learn about your students' language before you arrive, the more effective you can be in the classroom (as well as in every area of living).
It is crucial to a good teaching experience to match your instruction with the expectations of the school and with the needs of students. While this seems obvious, some respondents commented that English-speaking teachers would not prepare students for required exams or would fail to adapt their grading system to the local system. The Chinese respondents, especially, felt that the native-speaking teachers failed to modify their teaching to the Chinese way of learning. Thus, it is necessary to find out as much as possible about the kind of teaching, grading, etc. that you will encounter. Respondents on both surveys raised the issue of the attitude of English-speaking teachers towards the host culture.
Prepare non-offensive materials to take or send. No matter where you are going and no matter how much you think everything has been worked out, you will probably teach some classes you didn't anticipate. You may teach an entirely different set of classes. This must not deter you from sending or taking teaching materials because depending on where you are going, you may find no easy access to photocopying, no slide projectors, no books, or a wealth of completely unfamiliar materials. —How can you prepare materials when you don't know what you'll teach? Take a lot of good material. If you have a favorite set of materials, prepare to take or send them with enough copies for a class. Take a large variety of material. Students in most countries want to see American videos, too. Some tapes of American TV shows are a good idea. Why did we say "non-offensive"? Some material is obvious: materials that depict sexually explicit or violent acts are obvious. |
|
Many of our ESL materials assume students are in the U.S. and want to live here. These can be offensive to students overseas who simply want to study the language. Materials that present an American view of sensitive issues or that look critically at the points of views of others may be equally offensive. Teach diligently and explain methodology. A great deal of teaching overseas is teacher-centered, and teachers are expected to plan each part of the lesson thoroughly. Students and teachers responded negatively to what were perceived as unplanned classes.
In China, when told that American class activities try to make learning
fun, students and teachers asked "but when do you learn?"
Learning to them cannot be fun. You will probably want to
explain the pedagogical benefits of your methods, why you are playing
a game, etc. No matter how you value American English, if students are tested on British English, you will need to help them with British forms. No matter how much you value speaking, if students are only tested through written exams, you will need to give written English enough attention. Recognize that you are entering a place where people have been teaching and learning EFL, and they have often gone through rigorous training. Most work hard to keep abreast of current methodology. Hence, it is a good idea to identify the EFL methods used in the country and incorporate some into your teaching. If the primary or only method of teaching is rote learning, students are used to it and may consider it the only legitimate method. You may need to use a bit of it (or at least have students use it on your materials) until you can demonstrate that the other activities are producing better effects. Your L1 colleagues are a great source of knowledge in this area, and you can learn a great deal from them.
This criticism of native-speaking teachers is, we think, well
deserved. We have seen several EFL teachers who tried to show people
in other countries the way to teach English. Even worse, are those who try
to "show these people" how to live. As an outsider and foreigner, you are going to be treated as different and special -- in both ways you will appreciate and ways you won't. On the good side, being an outsider allows you to make mistakes in the language and culture--both in and out of the classroom. They won't expect you to know everything. It usually means you can ask for help. Also, it has the added benefit that you won't have to serve on committees, attend meetings, and do a lot of other work that people have in their home countries at their home job. On the negative side, you can't select the ways in which you'll be treated special. When being an outsider is not to your advantage (like having to pay more than other teachers), there will be nothing you can do about it. In your own culture, you're an adult, generally a responsible one. Overseas, you are a young child with less of a knowledge about how to be a responsible adult than a six-year old. Your assumptions about what a responsible adult is are all wrong, and you have to get used to that and start learning how to grow up in that culture. In the end, you will profit by expanding your ideas of what it means not only to be an adult, but to be human.
The attribute most frequently criticized in the Hungarian survey was a lack of training in teaching English. One student put it baldly: "Sometimes they come only because they can't find a proper job in their own country." In countries where teaching is taken most seriously, lack of professional preparation is noted and resented by both students and teachers as are the consequences.
One comment summed up the criticism nicely: "Being native is
not enough." As professionals in TESL and TEFL, we should not
encourage untrained students and friends to go abroad as teachers.
If your real goal is to convert people, religiously or
politically, or to establish business contacts, or do research, your
students and colleagues will probably resent your actions, not
consider you a true TEFL professional, and show a lack of trust in
other areas as well. You may even endanger the program you are
working for. Be prepared. Expect that you will be valued for your knowledge of the language, culture, and customs of your English-speaking country, and do whatever you can to enhance that knowledge before you go. Also, while your teaching style may be different from that of your host country, the differences may be valued.
Above all, your enthusiasm for your students and your
collegiality with your colleagues will be appreciated. Many of the problems that arise are because you are in a foreign culture. On the other hand, teaching and living overseas allows you to rethink who you are, and it is the crises that teach you the most. Rather than trying to avoid problems, try to accept the challenge that each problem offers about what you will learn about the culture, about teaching, or about yourself when the crisis is solved. |
|
|
|